Environmental feedback and networks shape cooperation levels over time

Evolutionary games on networks with negative edge-based environmental feedback

Social and Information Networks

Summary

This paper looks at how cooperation between individuals changes when the environment connecting them can be better or worse depending on their behavior. The authors show that when cooperation improves the environment but then encourages selfishness, complex patterns like stable cooperation or ongoing cycles can occur. They find that when people interact in sparse networks, cooperation tends to settle at moderate levels. Their approach uses mathematical models and computer simulations to show how these patterns depend on both environmental feedback and how connected the population is.

What this means in practice

  • For social network analysts: Model how changing environments influence cooperation patterns in social networks with varying connection densities.
  • For ecological modelers: Predict how local environmental changes driven by species interactions affect population cooperation and stability.

Authors

Katherine Betz, Feng Fu, Naoki Masuda

Abstract

Environmental feedback can fundamentally alter the game payoff structure underlying the evolution of cooperation. How feedback-evolving games interact with population structure under non-weak selection remains incompletely understood. We study an evolutionary game on networks in which each edge has a binary environmental state that determines the payoff matrix used by the two connected individuals. By assumption, cooperation tends to improve the local environment, which in turn favors defection, thereby creating negative feedback between strategies coupled with the environmental condition. We analyze the model under strong selection using a mean-field approximation, a pair approximation that tracks both strategy pairs and edge environments, and agent-based simulations. In well-mixed populations, the feedback can generate bistability between full cooperation and full defection, as well as sustained oscillations arising through a Hopf bifurcation. Sparse networks (i.e., with low nodes' degrees) can eliminate bistability, suppress oscillations, and produce stable intermediate levels of cooperation. The pair approximation captures these effects and generally agrees more closely with simulations on sparse networks than the mean-field approximation. Our results show that edge-based environmental feedback and network structure, such as density of edges, interact to determine whether the fraction of cooperators stabilizes or oscillates over time.