Minimax-H3 shows limited physical reasoning using multiple input types

Can MiniMax-H3 Reason About the Physical World? An Evaluation of Omni-Modal Generative Model

Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition

Summary

Minimax-H3 is a computer model that tries to understand and predict events by looking at different kinds of information, like pictures, videos, and sounds together. The paper asks whether using all these kinds together helps the model better understand the real world. To test this, the authors created tricky tasks where each kind of input only gives part of the story, so the model must combine clues to guess what happens next. They found that while the model is better at some tasks, like using video to make decisions, it struggles more with tasks relying on audio clues. This shows there is still work to do to improve how models mix different types of information to understand the world.

What this means in practice

  • For video content creators: Use improved video-based reasoning to generate or edit videos that reflect likely future scenes based on partial input sequences.
  • For audio engineers: Develop systems that better combine audio with visual data to clarify ambiguous sounds in multimedia editing contexts.

Authors

Haoyu Zhao, Zihao Zhao, Tianyu Deng, Ziqin Xu, Zihao Zhang, Xudong Wang, Jinxiang Guo, Chen Gao, Ziyi Ye, Yeying Jin, Jiaxi Gu, Zuxuan Wu, Shuicheng Yan

Abstract

Recent Omni-Modal Generative Models (Omni-Models) have advanced content generation toward unified modeling of text, images, video, and audio. MiniMax-H3 exemplifies this transition by combining multimodal context understanding with joint audio-visual generation in a shared latent framework. Its unified architecture raises a fundamental question: Can multimodal alignment improve the model's world reasoning, and what new evaluation paradigms do omni-modal inputs enable? To investigate this question, this work introduces a comprehensive evaluation framework organized around four complementary dimensions of physical world reasoning. Unlike existing evaluation frameworks for video generation and world models, which are often constrained by limited input modalities and evaluation settings where prompts closely match the target video content, our evaluation is specifically designed to exploit the multimodal inputs of Omni-Model. We construct a diverse set of novel tasks that require models to integrate complementary information across modalities. Specifically, we consider four scenarios, including implicit prompts paired with multiple frames, audio-image, prefix-videos, and audio-video inputs. Every single modality provides only partial evidence about the underlying event, requiring the model to jointly reason over the complementary semantic cues to infer latent event states and future dynamics. Across 517 evaluation instances, MiniMax-H3 achieves an overall success rate of 41.97%. Video-based Decision Reasoning yields the highest success rate at 56.00%, while Audio-based Disambiguation Reasoning is the weakest, reaching only 27.40%. These results indicate that effective multimodal integration remains key to fully exploiting the benefits of diverse input modalities. The project is available at https://github.com/gulucaptain/MiniMax-H3-Reason.