Compensating creators for AI training can increase their replacement

Paying Creators for Training Data Can Increase AI Displacement

Computer Science and Game TheoryArtificial Intelligence

Summary

Generative AI systems learn from content created by people, but sometimes this AI competes with those same creators. The authors show that if platforms pay creators for using their work to train AI, some creators might stop selling their own work and only provide data for AI training, letting AI take over their customers. Without paying for training data, platforms keep creators’ prices low so they keep selling, limiting AI’s takeover. Paying creators more helps them earn more but means customers might pay more and get less overall benefit.

What this means in practice

  • For platform operators: Design pricing and compensation strategies for creator content and AI output considering their impact on creator participation and user demand.
  • For digital content producers: Inform decisions about participating in AI training data markets versus selling original content based on compensation policies and AI competition.

Authors

Lijuan Luo, Emaad Manzoor, Nathan Yang, Fan Yao

Abstract

Generative AI increasingly competes with creators while using their content as training data. In response, policymakers have called for platforms to compensate creators for training data use and allow opting out. We study how such policies affect creator displacement in a model of a platform where creators choose whether to contribute training data and consumers choose between purchasing from creators and prompting generative AI trained on their content. When compensation is required, the low-quality creator chooses to remain solely as a training data supplier while AI fully displaces her demand, despite AI quality and the price the platform charges for AI-generated content being identical with and without compensation. Without compensation, the risk of losing creators and their training data constrains the platform to set the price of creators' content to preserve their demand. This constraint also prevents further AI displacement as AI improves, with the platform raising AI prices while keeping creators' prices and demand unchanged to prevent exit. Compensation increases creators' payoffs and total surplus but reduces consumer surplus. Our findings highlight how compensation policies for training data can shape creators' economic roles in a future with more capable generative AI.