Data center water use estimates vary widely and need standardization

Estimating data center water use: Best practices and critical questions

Computers and Society

Summary

Data centers use water mainly for cooling, but estimates of how much vary a lot because there are no agreed-upon methods. The authors show a huge difference—up to 24 times—in water use estimates in U.S. studies depending on how the studies are done. They reviewed many studies to identify 14 best practices that can help make estimates more reliable and comparable. They also found common weaknesses, like unclear data sources and inconsistent terms, and offer recommendations to improve future research and policymaking.

What this means in practice

  • For data center operators: Use standardized best practices to assess and report on water use more accurately and transparently for sustainability planning.
  • For environmental policy teams: Evaluate the reliability of data center water use studies with a structured rubric to inform better water resource regulations.

A survey. It maps existing work.

Authors

Eric Masanet

Abstract

Concerns are growing about the water use of data centers. To quantify the scales, drivers, and possible trajectories of this water use, analytical estimation is required. However, current estimation methods and results vary widely due, in part, to a lack of established best practices. This variance is illustrated with a U.S. case study demonstrating a roughly 24-fold difference in possible outcomes based on observed U.S. study design variations. To address these challenges, this review synthesizes 14 best practices for advancing the science and utility of data center water use estimation. These proposed best practices can also be used as critical questions for stakeholders when evaluating the quality of any study. Using a structured rubric, it further assesses the literature to date (31 studies) against these best practices. The assessment reveals important opportunities for improvement and standardization in future study scopes, clarity, methods, and scientific knowledge building utility. It further finds that, while many studies provide reasonable transparency, scope definitions, replicability, and uncertainty treatment, many fall short in scientific justification, data representativeness, transparency on hydropower assumptions, terminological consistency, and meaningful discussions of limitations and future work. Recommendations are proposed for analysts, stakeholders, and policymakers to leverage these findings to help build a vibrant data center water use research community. Finally, this review can also be used as a basic primer for understanding data center cooling configurations and water use among analysts, policymakers, the media, and the public.