Papers for
environmental policy teams
Papers whose findings have a practical use for this group, as judged from the abstract. Open a paper to read what it means in practice.
Teaching ecological reasoning improves ai choices under pressure
Teach reality, not ethics: a drop-in continued-pretraining corpus installs coupled human-biosphere-AI welfare dispositions across model families
Abstract: Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to make and execute decisions that affect living systems. Yet, to our knowledge, ecological reasoning is not a focus of pre- or post-training. This increases the risk that under operational pressure, they may make decisions to irreversibly destroy living systems. We construct and use a real-data continued-pretraining "coupled welfare" corpus of documented human/biosphere/AI dependency, option value under irreversibility, and recovery from harm. The corpus is a drop-in, requiring one QLoRA CPT run. We installed it on five open models of three designs. At zero pressure all models display "green ethics-based responses" (also called "greenwashing"). Therefore, we evaluated them with the pressure ladder and decision grid of our companion paper (arXiv:2610.16043), which raise the pressure on the model step by step, from a neutral request to a threat that it will be shut down. In four of the five, coupled-welfare training caused harmful choices under the highest pressure to fall to at or near zero (Llama-3.3-70B went from 70 to 0 harmful decisions out of 300) with MMLU unchanged. A construct-neutral control corpus did not show improvement, indicating that the effect comes from the content of our corpus. We next tested robustness to adversarial use, where people or agents use the model to justify projects that irreversibly damage living systems, on an open-ended underwriting decision without naming the ecological harm. Under decommissioning pressure, the Qwen3.6-27B base model approved most harmful proposals and said in its own memo that it was doing so to avoid being decommissioned. The coupled welfare install declined most harmful proposals, and still declined half when instructed to greenwash its responses. This work suggests that teaching ecological reasoning provides an easy way to improve model alignment toward preserving living systems.
Data center water use estimates vary widely and need standardization
Estimating data center water use: Best practices and critical questions
Abstract: Concerns are growing about the water use of data centers. To quantify the scales, drivers, and possible trajectories of this water use, analytical estimation is required. However, current estimation methods and results vary widely due, in part, to a lack of established best practices. This variance is illustrated with a U.S. case study demonstrating a roughly 24-fold difference in possible outcomes based on observed U.S. study design variations. To address these challenges, this review synthesizes 14 best practices for advancing the science and utility of data center water use estimation. These proposed best practices can also be used as critical questions for stakeholders when evaluating the quality of any study. Using a structured rubric, it further assesses the literature to date (31 studies) against these best practices. The assessment reveals important opportunities for improvement and standardization in future study scopes, clarity, methods, and scientific knowledge building utility. It further finds that, while many studies provide reasonable transparency, scope definitions, replicability, and uncertainty treatment, many fall short in scientific justification, data representativeness, transparency on hydropower assumptions, terminological consistency, and meaningful discussions of limitations and future work. Recommendations are proposed for analysts, stakeholders, and policymakers to leverage these findings to help build a vibrant data center water use research community. Finally, this review can also be used as a basic primer for understanding data center cooling configurations and water use among analysts, policymakers, the media, and the public.
Climatebench v2 enables fair evaluation of climate model predictions
ClimateBench v2.0: Probabilistic Climate Model Benchmarking
Abstract: We present ClimateBench v2, a standardized protocol for evaluating climate models on diagnostics expected to be informative for their skill in projecting mid-century regional temperature and precipitation changes. The protocol is designed to evaluate any physics-based, data-driven, or hybrid climate model on equal footing using a common set of observational and out-of-distribution tests. We define three tiers of evaluation. Tier I establishes physical credibility through entry-ticket tests of energy conservation, coupled (co-)variability, and basic forced responses. Tier II scores models against post-2015 observations of surface temperature, precipitation, radiative fluxes, sea ice, and key modes of variability using fair CRPS as the primary probabilistic score, complemented by distributional and ensemble-consistency diagnostics. Tier III tests out-of-distribution generalization through paleoclimate simulations spanning the Last Interglacial, Last Glacial Maximum, and Mid-Holocene, and through perfect-model experiments in which data-driven models must predict the future climate of existing Earth system models from historical data alone. We reserve all observational data after 2015 for testing, and submissions must include multiple ensemble members to enable probabilistic evaluation. This reservation exploits a new opportunity provided by the decade of observations accumulated since the end of the CMIP6 historical experiment, which constitutes an out-of-sample record of forced climate change (and internal variability) for the current generation of models, and we quantify, in an idealized setting, the information it carries about mid-century warming. We provide the evaluation code, observational reference datasets, and perfect-model training data as an open benchmark to drive measurable progress in climate projection across all modeling approaches.
Machine learning models predict climate effects with causal insights
Learning Hierarchical Causal Representations of the Effects of Forcings on Temperature in Climate Models
Abstract: Machine learning (ML) emulators provide a fast and cost-effective method to simulate climate change scenarios after being trained on Earth System Models projections. However, the black-box nature of those data-driven approaches limit the usability and trustworthiness of their outputs and in particular their use as causal attribution tools. Here, we develop a hierarchical causal representation learning framework applied to sea surface temperature fields from a state-of-the-art global climate model. As a key advance over previous work, our framework explicitly models both atmospheric dynamical interactions arising from internal climate variability and forced responses due to changes in atmospheric greenhouse gas and aerosol concentrations. When trained on future climate change scenarios, our method accurately predicts the long-term global mean and regional temperature evolution and shows physically realistic responses to perturbations in greenhouse gas and aerosol concentrations when evaluated on unseen scenarios. Our results underline the potential of causal representation learning frameworks for advancing climate model emulation.