German regional rail reform faces challenges after 30 years

A Success Model at the End of Its Life Cycle: 30 Years of Regionalised Regional Rail in Germany

Computers and Society

Summary

Germany transferred regional rail services from federal to state control in 1996, which led to more passengers and lower costs. However, after 30 years, the system faces problems like fewer bids for contracts and complicated overlapping government structures. The authors show that funding no longer covers services properly, and they suggest reforms including simplifying authorities, standardizing trains, and adjusting funding to real infrastructure costs.

What this means in practice

  • For public transport planners: Design improved regional rail systems by consolidating authorities and standardizing rolling stock to overcome current structural flaws.
  • For transport funding agencies: Develop funding schemes indexed to actual infrastructure costs to ensure service volumes are financially sustainable post charge cap removal.

A position paper. It proposes an approach and reports no results.

Authors

Lukas Iffländer

Abstract

On 1 January 1996, Germany transferred responsibility for regional passenger rail services from the federal government to the states. Three decades later, passenger-kilometres have doubled and competitive tendering has lowered operating costs substantially, making regionalisation the most successful element of the German rail reform. Its organisational model, however, has reached the end of its life cycle: tenders now attract on average only 1.3 bids, 26 contracting authorities and some 60 transport associations maintain overlapping structures, rolling-stock procurement has repeatedly shifted risk onto passengers, and since the Court of Justice of the European Union struck down the German track-access charge cap in 2026, funding no longer covers the ordered service volume. This article reviews the motives and results of regionalisation, identifies three structural design flaws, and argues for a second reform: consolidating authorities, standardising rolling stock, deciding between a repaired market model and integrated public operation, and indexing funding to real infrastructure cost development. The submission contains an English translation followed by the German original.