Patient-specific simulations improve tricuspid valve modeling accuracy

Patient-specific Modeling of the Tricuspid Valve from 3D Transesophageal Echocardiography

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

Summary

The tricuspid valve in the heart can be hard to model precisely using clinical images alone because important parts aren't clearly visible and tissue properties can't be measured directly. The authors created a method that uses 3D heart scans combined with detailed measurements from real human valves taken out of the body to build better computer models of this valve. They tested their method on ten valves, showing their models matched real valve shapes closely and identified which factors impact accuracy most. This work helps build tools that could assist doctors in planning valve repairs tailored to each patient.

What this means in practice

  • For cardiac surgeons: Simulate individual patient tricuspid valve mechanics to guide personalized repair strategies before surgery.
  • For medical device designers: Use improved valve models to design and test repair devices or implants that better accommodate patient-specific anatomy.

Authors

Davide Tondi, Vijay K. Dubey, Collin E. Haese, Colton J. Kostelnik, Mrudang Mathur, Sumedh Seetharam, Amin Silvani, Alison M. Pouch, Jakob Christoph Voran, Felix Kreidel, Marnie Goldmann, Adrian Buganza Tepole, William D. Meador, Marcin Malinowski, Magda Piekarska, Austin Goodyke, Issam D. Moussa, Matthew R. Summers, Robyn Fong, Matthew M. Duda, Kelly C. Higa, William Hiesinger, Tomasz A. Timek, Jan N. Fuhg, Emiliano Votta, Manuel K. Rausch

Abstract

Purpose: Image-based patient-specific simulations of the tricuspid valve (TV) could support repair planning. However, clinical images incompletely resolve the chordal anatomy and cannot directly determine tissue properties, which hinders the development of such models. We developed and evaluated a framework that simulates the TV from clinical images and addresses these limitations using measurements on explanted human valves. Methods: We reconstructed ten functionally competent human TVs from 3D transesophageal echocardiography. Following manual segmentation, we automatically built finite element models with synthetic chordae and with leaflet thickness, chordal insertion density, and tissue properties informed by ex vivo human measurements. Next, we used shape matching and force-based chordal-length adjustment to simulate valve closure. We also assessed inter-observer segmentation variability and sensitivity to chordal insertion density, leaflet stiffness, leaflet thickness, and chordal size and material properties. Results: Per-valve median geometric errors were 0.61-1.13 mm relative to the morphed references and 0.55-0.95 mm relative to the image-derived surfaces. Coaptation covered 20-42% of the leaflet area, and median leaflet stresses ranged from 7.6 to 16.9 kPa. Inter-observer variability in segmentation most strongly affected coaptation area. Of the population-based inputs, insertion density and leaflet stiffness most affected geometric error. Thickness primarily affected stress, whereas chordal size and material properties had limited effects. Conclusion: Clinical echocardiography, supplemented with ex vivo human tissue data, enabled patient-specific simulation of ten human TVs. This framework provides a foundation for investigating valve mechanics and developing repair-planning tools, while sensitivity analyses identify priorities for model refinement and uncertainty assessment.