Framework explains how to find truth in biased stories and arguments

The Tiglath Pileser principle and models of persuasion

Logic in Computer Science

Summary

People often hear stories or claims that might be biased or even intentionally misleading. This paper introduces a way to think about how listeners can still find reliable information within those stories by tracking connections to the truth. The authors build a mathematical framework that describes how information changes when people share it strategically, even over time. They show how this approach can be used to understand real historical stories and how beliefs form when you only have partial or twisted information.

What this means in practice

  • For legal analysts: Provide formal tools to assess the reliability of testimony and evidence affected by bias or strategic misinformation.
  • For intelligence analysts: Assist in evaluating and updating beliefs about sources when intelligence reports may contain deliberate deception.

A theory result. No direct application yet.

Authors

Willem Conradie, Krishna Manoorkar, Alessandra Palmigiano, Apostolos Tzimoulis, Nachoem Wijnberg

Abstract

This paper develops a formal framework for analysing how agents extract reliable information from narratives and communicative interactions involving strategic deception. Building on Rubinstein and Glazer's models of persuasion, we introduce Tiglath-Pileser relations, a generalization of codex-based guidance relations, to formalize Baruch Halpern's Tiglath-Pileser principle: despite systematic bias, reported claims must retain a connection to the truth. We analyse these relations set-theoretically and axiomatically, identifying conditions for their successful application in persuasion. Our dynamic approach examines how such relations are formed, revised, and strategically manipulated, extending existing models beyond one-shot interactions. Two case studies, including a formal reconstruction of Halpern's interpretation of the biblical account of King David, illustrate the framework's application to historiographical reasoning. Combining logic, epistemic reasoning, and game theory, the paper provides an account of belief formation and truth approximation under partial information and strategic manipulation.