Trust and transparency in ai-altered linkedin posts match human-written ones
Perceived Trust and Transparency in AI-Altered vs. Human-Written LinkedIn Posts
Human-Computer Interaction
Summary
This study looked at how people judge trust and honesty in LinkedIn posts that were either written by humans or edited by AI after a human draft. The researchers found that people could not reliably tell if a post was AI-edited and generally thought the posts were trustworthy and clear, no matter the writing source. Interestingly, posts edited by AI with more detailed instructions, even those adding new ideas, were sometimes seen as more trustworthy and transparent. This suggests AI editing doesn’t harm, and can even improve, how people see social media posts.
What this means in practice
- •For social media managers: Design AI-assisted editing workflows that maintain or improve perceived trust in professional posts without worrying about negative detection effects.
- •For content marketing teams: Use detailed AI prompts to refine drafts, potentially increasing audience trust and transparency in marketing messages on platforms like LinkedIn.
Authors
Thomas Christian Joos, Azza Bouleimen, Anikó Hannák, Nicolò Pagan
Abstract
People increasingly draft a social media post themselves and then let an AI model refine it (AI-altered), a common but understudied middle case between fully human-written and fully AI-generated content. We ask whether this changes how trustworthy and transparent readers perceive the post to be, and whether they can even tell. We first analyze real ChatGPT conversations (WildChat) to find how people actually alter social media posts, which we use to design realistic alteration prompts. We then run a pre-registered, within-subjects online experiment (n=214) in which participants rate unlabeled human-written and AI-altered LinkedIn-style posts for perceived trustworthiness and transparency, and separately judge whether each post was AI-altered. We find that AI-alteration itself has no detectable effect on either perceived trustworthiness or transparency (both estimates near zero, not significant). At the same time, readers did not reliably detect AI-alteration (49\% accuracy, near chance) and defaulted to assuming human authorship when unsure. However, our analysis shows significant differences in transparency and trustworthiness ratings across the specific post, the AI model, as well as the prompt used to alter it. For instance, more detailed prompts raise both perceived trustworthiness and transparency but also make the alteration more detectable. Surprisingly, the prompt that shifted ratings most also asked the model to add one new idea absent from the original post: readers nonetheless rated this AI-invented, unverifiable content as more trustworthy and transparent.