Scientific paper names cause confusion across research fields
"PRISM" Is Not All You Need: Cross-Topic Name Collisions and Scientific Paper Retrieval
Information RetrievalDigital Libraries
Summary
Scientific papers often use names that appear in multiple research areas, making it hard to find the right paper just by its name. The authors studied over half a million AI papers and found this name confusion is growing much faster between topics than within a single topic. They tested different search methods and found that adding context like abstracts helps reduce confusion but doesn’t eliminate it entirely. Their work provides tools and data to help improve how scientific papers are found despite these naming overlaps.
What this means in practice
- •For digital library engineers: Improve search tools in scientific databases by handling ambiguous names that appear in different fields using context-aware ranking methods.
- •For ai assistant developers: Enhance research assistants to better identify and distinguish similarly named scientific papers across topics by using title and abstract information with language model ranking.
Authors
Jingjie Ning, Xueqi Li, Yibo Kong
Abstract
Scientific names increasingly connect papers from different research topics, leaving readers to recover a paper's identity from context. We study this convergence in 564,861 AI-related arXiv records. Cross-topic name collision grows 4.33-fold from a pooled 2020-2022 reference to 2026, compared with 1.12-fold within topics. A second sentence encoder reproduces the pattern, and name-group resampling quantifies its uncertainty. Fixed word-frequency bands locate the main increase in an intermediate-frequency vocabulary shared by many research areas. We then measure the ambiguity that remains after supplying research clues. With the same three-term query construction, shared-name targets retain matched identification deficits of 25.7 percentage points under title-based BM25 and 6.9 points under title-plus-abstract E5. Within fixed same-name candidates, listwise language-model ranking reaches 89.2% using the query and candidate titles. Topic-specific comparisons show that context resolves more cross-topic ambiguity. The evaluation separates candidate competition, document fields, and contextual ranking through lexical, dense, and language-model baselines. Source-linked cases and a portable evaluation collection make the phenomenon inspectable and reusable for scientific retrieval and research assistants.