Jet tagger performance differences traced to missed physics information
What the Primary Lund Plane Omits: A Model-Stitching Diagnosis of a Jet-Tagger Representation Gap
Artificial Intelligence
Summary
Jet taggers are tools used to identify particle jets in physics experiments, but some do better because of the information they use. The authors show that a commonly used jet representation called the primary Lund plane misses important details, causing weaker performance compared to a Particle Transformer method. By combining parts of both approaches, they pinpoint that the problem is missing representation, not poor computation. Adding back the missed parts improves performance, especially for identifying top quark jets.
What this means in practice
- •For particle physics software developers: Improve jet tagging algorithms by including full declustering tree information to better capture physics features missed by primary Lund plane representations.
- •For computational physics engineers: Use model stitching tools to diagnose representational weaknesses in complex particle classification models, enhancing their interpretability and accuracy.
Authors
Saurabh Rai, Sanmay Ganguly
Abstract
Lund-plane and Particle Transformer (ParT) jet taggers can differ in performance because one representation is weaker, or because a weaker downstream computation reads an adequate one. Standalone performance cannot separate these. Model stitching can: it links the frozen early layers of one network to the frozen late layers of another through a single trained linear map. As a positive control we use an incomplete Lund representation, the primary declustering branch, whose deficit is known independently. Stitched into ParT's downstream, it reaches a background rejection at least as much as its own downstream recovers, yet far below ParT's background rejection: the deficit is representational, not computational. A hypergraph reader over splitting triplets does no better, ruling out higher-order correlations as the cause. The gap is invisible in AUC, which stays within 1\% of its target value, and appears only in background rejection at low signal efficiency. It localizes to 0.6\% of background jets, at and above the top mass, with more constituents but fewer primary splittings than typical background. Rebuilding the representation on the full Cambridge/Aachen declustering tree repairs the deficit as predicted: standalone rejection rises, closing 72\% of the gap. Masking nodes at inference shows the repaired network still relies almost entirely on the primary branch; the secondary splittings make the representation learnable rather than supplying information it reads. Along the primary branch, the widest-angle splitting, near the top and $W$ opening angles, is worth nearly twice a random one. For quark/gluon tagging the primary branch is far less deficient, retaining 77.6\% of ParT's rejection (46.9\% for top), and the full tree closes only 33\% of the gap (72\% for top).