AI agents not instantly useful for industrial robot programming
Can AI Agents Help Robotic Engineers? Lessons from Two Focus Days in Industry
Software EngineeringArtificial Intelligence
Summary
Using AI agents that can write code on their own works well for some software developers, but robotic engineers program robots using special languages and tools, which makes it different. The authors studied a small company that codes industrial robots using AI agents, and found that the AI helped mainly with repetitive coding tasks, but didn’t make the engineers faster overall. However, the engineers got better at using the AI over time, and the AI improved when adapted to the robot programming domain. The study shows that companies need to invest effort and time to train engineers and customize AI before it becomes truly productive.
What this means in practice
- •For robotic software engineers: Plan training and adaptation time when introducing AI agents for robot programming to improve effectiveness in industrial settings.
- •For industrial automation managers: Support gradual integration of AI tools for robot programming by allocating time and resources for engineers to learn and adapt AI use.
Authors
Salim Fares, Steffen Herbold
Abstract
Software developers increasingly use AI agents that execute multi-step programming tasks on their own. However, it is unclear if and how this transfers to robotic engineering, where engineers program industrial robots in niche, vendor-specific languages and rely on visual feedback from simulation tools. Within this paper, we report a case study on the use of AI agents by an SME that programs industrial robots. Our results show that the agent did not make the engineers more productive, with the exception of a task that required the generation of highly repetitive code. However, the results with the agent improved over time, as the engineers learned how to use it and the agent was adapted to the domain. Moreover, the experience with AI mattered more for the success with the agent than the experience with robotic engineering. This shows that AI agents are not a plug-and-play solution. Instead, companies must train their engineers on the usage of agents, plan time for a learning curve, and ensure that agent configurations match the domain and developer requirements. The strong learning curve we observed further implies that studies on productivity gains with AI should be longitudinal, as they otherwise miss how engineers adopt agents in practice.