Scholarly reading paths reveal personal curiosity and research styles
Feeling Wistful: Reflecting on Scholarly Sensibilities with Creative Reading Traces
Human-Computer Interaction
Summary
People often explore research topics before they know exactly what they want to find. The authors studied how researchers browse scholarly content in a personal and curious way. They created a tool called Wistful that records the unique routes researchers take through articles, showing how their interests and knowledge shape their reading. This helps make those reading choices visible and easier to reflect on or share with others. Such reading paths can help understand how scholars think when exploring ideas.
What this means in practice
- •For scholarly database designers: Incorporate reading trace features to enable users to revisit and compare their exploratory paths through academic content.
- •For digital library developers: Design interfaces that capture and visualize users’ personal research journeys to support reflection and collaboration.
Authors
Sophia W. Liu, Kate Chier, Shm Garanganao Almeda, Max Kreminski, Bjoern Hartmann
Abstract
Researchers often read before they can articulate what they are looking for. As AI increasingly mediates scholarly search and synthesis, understanding and preserving the idiosyncratic judgments guiding early exploration become important. We call these evolving orientations scholarly sensibilities. To understand curiosity-driven reading, we first examined Wikipedia rabbitholing, a self-directed browsing practice, then designed Wistful, a research probe for open-ended scholarly exploration that captures reading paths as creative reading traces. We studied Wistful with 16 HCI researchers---eight junior and eight senior---in comparison with their usual workflows. Researchers approached the same scholarly landscape differently, with familiarity and personal interests shaping what they pursued and semantic proximity and scholarly links shaping their paths. Their traces made these differences visible and let readers revisit and compare their paths. We position creative reading traces as artifacts for reflection and exchange and as a means of studying how scholarly sensibilities are expressed through reading.