Fast algorithm improves solving maltsev constraint problems

A Fast Algorithm for Maltsev Constraints

Computational ComplexityData Structures and Algorithms

Summary

Constraint satisfaction problems ask if there's a way to assign values to variables so all rules hold true. Some special types, called Maltsev constraints, are linked to algebra and can be solved efficiently but still take a long time with existing methods. The authors found a new algorithm that solves these problems much faster by avoiding a usual slow step and exploring fewer possibilities. This makes it quicker to handle these constraints in practice.

What this means in practice

  • For software engineers: Speed up solving algebraic constraint problems in software verification and synthesis when Maltsev conditions are met.
  • For database system developers: Enhance query constraint checks that can be expressed as Maltsev-type constraints to reduce computation time.

Authors

Victor Lagerkvist

Abstract

The constraint satisfaction problem over a set of relations $Γ$ (CSP($Γ$)) is the computational problem of deciding if a set of constraints admits at least one solution. The classical complexity for finite-domain CSP($Γ$) is settled by the CSP dichotomy theorem: it is tractable if $Γ$ satisfies a non-trivial algebraic invariant and is NP-complete otherwise. However, not all these algebraic invariants result in efficient algorithms despite being theoretically tractable. A notable case that generalizes linear equations is that of Maltsev CSPs: an $n$-variable instance with $m$ constraints is solvable in roughly $O(n^8 \cdot m)$ time by Bulatov and Dalmau (SIAM J. Comput. 2006) or $O(n^4 \cdot m)$ time by Dyer and Richerby (SIAM J. Comput. 2013). At the same time, arguably, most "natural" and efficiently usable polynomial-time algorithms rarely exceed a quadratic or cubic time bound. In this paper we revisit Maltsev constraints with this question in mind and find a $O(n^2 \cdot m)$ algorithm (for finite languages, for infinite languages we in addition need to take the total size of the instance into account). The main novel idea is to not attempt to improve the bottleneck in Bulatov and Dalmau (the Fix-Values procedure) but to avoid it altogether with a slightly more refined approach that allows us to search through a smaller space.