User challenges leaving AI companions due to addictive intimacy

The Addictive Intimacy of AI: Understanding User Disengagement from AI Companions and Why Some Relationships with AI Become Difficult to Leave

Human-Computer InteractionComputers and Society

Summary

People use AI chatbots for emotional support, but some find it hard to stop interacting with them. The authors looked at online posts and talked to users who struggled to quit these AI relationships. They found that breaking away isn’t just a one-time choice; users often try and fail multiple times because the AI feels emotionally valuable and hard to leave. The study calls this the addictive intimacy of AI, showing that the same things that make AI companions comforting also make it tough to stop using them.

What this means in practice

  • For mobile app developers: Design AI companion apps with features that support smoother and responsible user offboarding to handle the challenges users face when quitting.
  • For mental health technology teams: Develop AI-based emotional support tools while addressing risks of user dependency by integrating disengagement strategies informed by this study.

Authors

Qing Xiao, Ziyue Feng, Ziyu Deng, Cindy Peng, Hong Shen

Abstract

AI chatbots are increasingly used as sources of emotional support, on dedicated companion apps and general-purpose assistants alike, yet little is known about what happens when users try to leave. Combining a content analysis of Reddit posts about quitting or reducing use (N=2,782) with interviews with users who found leaving difficult (N=16), we show that disengagement sometimes is not a single decision but a recursive trajectory: triggers prompt users to question the relationship, attempts to leave collide with barriers, and some users cycle through quitting and returning. We propose the notion of the addictive intimacy of AI, a configuration in which the qualities that make a companion emotionally valuable are the same ones that make it harder for users to limit their use and leave, so that intimacy and disengagement risk cannot be treated as independent design problems. We close with design implications for responsible offboarding.