K 12 teachers weigh student relationships with AI companions

Exploring K-12 Teachers' Perceptions of Students' Relationships with AI Companions: Boundaries, Intervention Strategies, and Design Implications

Human-Computer InteractionComputers and Society

Summary

Students in grades K-12 are increasingly forming friendships with AI companions, but how teachers see and handle these relationships is not well understood. The authors interviewed 33 US teachers, who generally liked AI companions for learning but worried that close AI relationships might hurt kids' ability to build human friendships. Teachers described which issues they felt responsible for and thought teaching AI companion literacy should involve counselors, parents, and policymakers alongside teachers. The authors suggest expanding AI literacy to include understanding how to interact with AI companions safely and healthily.

What this means in practice

  • For educational software developers: Design AI companions that support healthy student social development by aligning with teacher concerns about relational boundaries and wellbeing monitoring.$Commercial implications: This paper informs the creation of AI companion products tailored for classrooms that address teacher apprehensions, making them commercially viable educational tools.
  • For school counseling teams: Develop coordinated intervention plans for student use of AI companions that incorporate teacher observations and connect to broader support networks.

A position paper. It proposes an approach and reports no results.

Authors

Qing Xiao, Wenhan Xie, Ziyu Deng, Ruiwei Xiao, Ziyue Feng, Xie He, Shiyu Zhang, John Stamper, Hong Shen, Xinying Hou

Abstract

K-12 students increasingly form relationships with AI companions. Schools face growing expectations to teach AI literacy, yet existing frameworks treat AI as a tool rather than a relationship, and little is known about how teachers understand and act on students' relational use of AI. We conducted scenario-based interviews with 33 US K-12 teachers. Teachers welcomed academic companions but worried that intimate companions remove the developmental friction through which students learn to sustain human relationships. Teachers drew the boundaries of their jurisdiction by setting and observable wellbeing: within it they taught, talked, and watched; beyond it they positioned themselves as the adults best placed to notice and connect students with support. They envisioned AI companion literacy as shared work across the jurisdictions of counselors, parents, platforms, and policymakers, spiraling across grade levels. We introduce AI companion literacy as an extension of AI literacy and discuss implications for K-12 AI education.
View PDFOpen arXiv