Papers for

evolutionary biologists

Papers whose findings have a practical use for this group, as judged from the abstract. Open a paper to read what it means in practice.

Social learning supports but does not drive evolution of flexible traits

The forces at hand: social learning is permissive, not instructive, for the evolution of phenotypic plasticity

Abstract: Evolution can favour a trait for two reasons: an instructive cause makes selection favour the trait; a permissive one lets it persist once selection no longer removes it. The distinction matters most for phenotypic plasticity and its replacement by inherited behaviour, genetic assimilation, the Baldwin effect. Social learning is credited with favouring plasticity on evidence that cannot tell the two apart: how much plasticity remains at the end of a simulation. Here we show, analytically and computationally, which role it plays in a minimal model of learning and evolution. Writing expected fitness as a function of plasticity, we find that environmental change is the only source of benefit from plasticity, and the social channel enters only its cost. Simulation confirms this: in a static environment selection against plasticity never reverses sign at any channel strength; when the environment changes, it reverses at a threshold the channel lowers, and without the channel the population collapses before reaching it. Social learning is permissive, not instructive: it supplies the means to be plastic, never the reason. For the debate over whether plasticity leads evolution, this is one case settled by measurement: environmental change directs, socially inherited information permits, and neither suffices alone.

Sat 7 NovNeural and Evolutionary Computing
The gist
Evolution often favors traits because they help survival or simply because they don't get removed. The authors studied how social learning affects traits that change based on the environment, called phenotypic plasticity. They found that environmental changes actually drive the benefit of being flexible, while social learning only helps traits stick around by lowering their costs. In other words, social learning allows flexibility to survive but doesn’t cause it to evolve.
Open → 2611.10986v1

Brain size grows first in stable environments before changing ones

Big Brains and Changing Environments: Cause or Consequence?

Abstract: Large brains are metabolically costly, and associations with changing environments do not imply they evolved there, as the Cognitive Buffer Hypothesis (CBH) would suggest. They may instead evolve in stable conditions and later facilitate colonization of changing environments. Using neuro-evolution in an artificial seasonal foraging task, we compared agents evolving exclusively in changing environments to agents first evolved in static environments before transitioning. Results show that larger neural networks in dynamic environments arise mainly from prior static evolution, achieving superior performance under unpredictable changes. Our results challenge strict CBH predictions, provide agent-based (computational) support for a colonization-based account and highlight the role of evolutionary history in brain size evolution.

Mon 14 SeptNeural and Evolutionary ComputingArtificial Intelligence
The gist
Bigger brains cost a lot of energy, so scientists want to know why animals evolved them. This study shows that animals might develop large brains in stable environments first, not just in changing ones as some ideas suggest. Later, these bigger brains help animals survive better when their surroundings become unpredictable. The authors ran computer simulations where virtual agents evolved bigger brains in static settings before facing changing conditions, and those with large brains did better. This challenges previous beliefs and highlights that the history of evolution matters in brain size changes.
Open → 2609.15569v1