Analysis of trade-offs in urban heat mitigation using a Bayesian Optimization framework for an urban canopy layer model
Abstract: To mitigate the challenges of climate change and intensifying heat stress in urban areas, local adaptation strategies are discussed and introduced in cities worldwide. To understand processes and potential trade-offs of these strategies a Bayesian optimization and surrogate modeling framework was employed to investigate urban parameter ranges of heat mitigation strategies with focus on three thermal metrics: daytime air temperature, Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI), and nighttime air temperature. Based on an urban street canyon configuration, it was shown that heat mitigation measures that reduce daytime air temperature and UTCI are often associated with higher nighttime temperatures. This results in a curved Pareto front that reflects the trade-off between daytime and nighttime thermal comfort. Under identical forcing conditions, different urban configurations, varying in geometry, vegetation, and surface characteristics, are shown to alter peak canyon air temperature by up to 5.2~$^\circ$C during the day and 2.6~$^\circ$C at night, while UTCI varies by up to 7.9~$^\circ$C, demonstrating that favorable urban configurations can substantially mitigate microclimatic heat stress. These findings suggest that combining multi-objective Bayesian optimization and surrogate modeling can help bridge the gap between computationally intensive climate simulations and practical decision-making in urban planning. An interactive visualization tool was developed to explore these trade-offs, making the often opposing relationships between urban parameters and the three thermal metrics directly accessible to planners.