Papers for

ai knowledge engineers

Papers whose findings have a practical use for this group, as judged from the abstract. Open a paper to read what it means in practice.

Different types of negation change how logical reasoning works

Modus Tollens and Counterfactuals and Counterfactual Reasoning Based on Three Types of Negation

Abstract: Modus Tollens (MT) is a classical logical inference rule, while counterfactuals are hypothetical statements that are contrary to facts, and counterfactual reasoning is a process of reasoning based on counterfactuals. Negation is an indispensable core concept in them. In this paper, based on the logical systems LCOI&PLCOI with contradictory negation, opposite negation and intermediary negation, we propose three variants of Modus Tollens corresponding to distinct negation types, namely MTC: Modus Tollens based on contradictory negation, MTO: Modus Tollens based on opposite negation, and MTI: Modus Tollens based on intermediary negation. We define the implications within MTC, MTO and MTI, provide the truth value algorithms of MTC, MTO and MTI, and discuss the reducibility of these algorithms. To incorporate these three types of negation into counterfactuals and counterfactual reasoning, we differentiate counterfactuals into two types based on whether they possess logical negation, thereby proposing three counterfactuals and counterfactuals reasoning based on different logical negations. In this paper, we further argue that the three counterfactuals reasoning based on different logical negations have the same inference form as MTC, MTO and MTI, respectively. In other words, they share the same inference structure. As a result, the truth value algorithms for MTC, MTO and MTI can be as the truth value algorithms for the three counterfactuals reasoning based on different logical negations. The algorithms indicates that if the first premise of the reasoning is true, the truth values of the reasoning conclusions are identical to the truth values of the three negative premises in the reasoning premises, respectively. This reflects the consistency and accuracy of the truth value algorithms.

Mon 7 SeptArtificial Intelligence
The gist
Logical reasoning often uses a rule called Modus Tollens to draw conclusions when statements are negated. This paper shows there are three different kinds of negation—contradictory, opposite, and intermediary—and each leads to a different way of applying Modus Tollens. The authors connect these forms of negation and reasoning to counterfactual statements, which imagine what would happen if things were different from reality. Their work provides algorithms that predict the truth values of conclusions depending on the kind of negation used, helping clarify how negations affect reasoning.
Open → 2609.07483v1